Original B Safe vs B Safe 35
January 29, 2016
I bought the Britax B Safe 35 in March 2015 when I found out I was pregnant. I used it for a very short period of time, until the handle recall came out and mine was an affected model. It is a very heavy seat to begin with, so I am not surprised the handle was snapping supporting the weight of the seat. I initially chose a Britax because I heard great things about the B Ready stroller as a double stroller (and it really is great. They thought of everything.) The B Safe 35 infant seat is compact, which is convenient, and the sunshade is full coverage-it was a sleep machine for my newborn. As I used it though, I started to see its quality degrade very quickly. The base started to split on the plastic seams where the recline foot was located, and the clips to the base would stick when attempting to release the car seat. The handle was visibly bending when held with the baby in it and didn't seem like the right type of plastic for a car seat handle-too soft. I called customer service at Britax and they agreed to exchange the B Safe 35 under warranty for the original B Safe, which I LOVE. Although it doesn't have as much sun coverage, the original B Safe is much more user friendly. The seat is wider to accommodate a bigger framed child, but somehow didn't take up any more space in my car when fitting 3 across.I found the base easier to install because it is open in many spaces and much LIGHTER. The baseless install of the original B Safe was much easier because of the upward curve of the leg area, although I didn't have to do that for our other car since an extra base is almost $30 cheaper. The original B Safe also rocks when placed on the floor because it is curved, like all the other infant seats I've used EXCEPT the B Safe 35! I can see why the B Safe was redesigned to have more competitive luxury features, but none of them were essential to the ease of use of the product (in my opinion). If anything, the shape and weight of the B Safe 35 made it MORE difficult to lift in and out of the base/stroller as well as carry independently. Ironically, the B Ready stroller I bought second hand was included in the top seat/belly bar recall as well since it was a 2012 model. I LOVE the original B Safe/B Ready combination and plan use them together for a long time as our family grows past 2 children. Britax customer service was amazing throughout all of this, and I plan to buy more of their products in the future mostly based on the fact that they seem to respond to what their customers think of the quality, safety and usability of their products.
This product review was collected by the manufacturer.